ianmcginty logo (1)

Written by 12:16 am Comics

Did Scott Pilgrim die in the Comics?

Did scott pilgrim die in the Comics

Did scott pilgrim die in the Comics

Scott Pilgrim is the beloved protagonist of the popular graphic novel series Scott Pilgrim by Bryan Lee O’Malley. Both the books and their cinematic adaptation, directed by Edgar Wright, have garnered a massive cult following over the years.

This has naturally led fans to closely dissect even the smallest details of the story. One question that seems to persist is whether Scott actually died at the end of the sixth and final Scott Pilgrim book. Let’s take a closer look at the evidence.

What Happens at the End of Scott Pilgrim’s Precious Little Life?

In the climax of Book 6, Scott finally defeats the sinister Gideon Graves after a long and brutal fight. Scott emerges victorious, winning the love of his life, Ramona Flowers. The book then flashes forward into the future, showing Scott’s life six years later. Scott seems to be happy, living in domestic bliss with Ramona.

However, there are strange hints that something is amiss. Scott acts overly enthusiastic, almost manic at times. He also keeps insisting that he is “fine,” even when no one asks him. Ramona seems concerned, even scared, by Scott’s behavior. The book ends on an ambiguous note, with Scott screaming as his eyes turn completely black.

So what does this cryptic ending mean? Did Scott really die at the end of his fight with Gideon? Or is something more subtle and nuanced going on?

Evidence That Scott Is Dead

Here are some of the biggest hints that Scott Pilgrim died at the end of Book 6:

  • Scott’s unnaturally cheerful behavior indicates he could be in denial about his death.
  • His insistence that he is “fine” also points to Scott hiding a darker truth.
  • Ramona asks Scott, “Is this the afterlife?” heavily implies she knows Scott is dead.
  • The final splash page shows Scott with fully black eyes, a common visual cue for death in comics.
  • Gideon impales Scott through the chest with a sword, a seemingly fatal blow.
  • The books establish that when someone dies in the Scott Pilgrim universe, they can come back as an undead zombie slave.

With this evidence, it seems quite likely that Scott did, in fact, die fighting Gideon. The final pages show Scott as an upbeat zombie, explaining his strange behavior. While Scott got the metaphorical “life” he wanted with Ramona, he had to literally die to achieve it.

Counter Evidence That Scott Is Still Alive

However, the theory of Scott’s death is not ironclad. There are also some clues that he may have somehow survived:

  • Scott has no visible wounds by the end, implying he healed from Gideon’s blows.
  • If Scott died, why doesn’t he have blue skin and hair like the other undead characters?
  • Bryan Lee O’Malley once said in an interview that the ending is “open to interpretation,” neither fully confirming nor denying Scott’s death.

So while Scott being dead makes sense, there are also signs pointing to more ambiguous explanations.

Other Possible Explanations for the Ending

If Scott did not die, as the straightforward reading suggests, what else could be happening? Here are some alternate theories about the finale’s surreal events:

Scott is trapped in a magical illusion

Gideon was an expert at manipulating minds. Perhaps Scott is trapped in an elaborate illusion while comatose, living out his perfect life with Ramona. This would explain the ending’s dreamlike quality. However, this theory cannot account for Ramona seemingly being aware that something is wrong with Scott.

Scott is split into good and evil halves

Another premise is that Scott’s personality split into two halves during his fight with Gideon—his nice side and his inner dark side, given form. The manic, cheerful Scott we see would be his good half, while the Scott with black eyes would be his repressed, dark half. This symbolic interpretation fits with the series’ video game logic.

The ending is purposefully ambiguous

There is also the possibility that Bryan Lee O’Malley deliberately left the ending open-ended. This allows fans to debate the meaning endlessly. The author maybe wanted to conclude his epic love story on an uncertain note rather than definitively killing the protagonist, whom fans grew to love.

Ultimately, there is no consensus on what happens to Scott at the end. The possibilities explored above are just some of the major theories proposed by fans and critics over the years. O’Malley has been tight-lipped, preferring readers to decide for themselves whether Scott lived or died. This perhaps makes the enigmatic ending all the more legendary.

How Does the Movie Handle Scott’s Fate?

While the Scott Pilgrim film adaptation is mostly faithful to the books, it notably alters the finale. In the movie version, Scott clearly survives his battle after Gideon impales him. Scott even says the line “I’m fine” himself, eliminating the ambiguous undertones.

Director Edgar Wright likely wanted the film to wrap up on a definitively feel-good note. Having the hero die might have felt too dour for mainstream audiences. So rather than grapple with the complex theories about Scott’s fate, the simpler option was taken.

For movie fans unfamiliar with the books, simply getting the girl he fought so hard for provides a classic Hollywood ending. But for hardcore fans of the graphic novels, changing the finale sacrifices the original elliptical ending that sparked so much discussion.

Conclusion: Scott’s Fate Is Meant to Be Debated

So did Scott Pilgrim live or die in the comics? As we have seen, strong cases can be made either way. Ultimately, there may be no definitive answer. But this ambiguous ending was likely intentional. Bryan Lee O’Malley constructed the conclusion to start endless debate within the passionate Scott Pilgrim fandom.

The unresolved ending is a fitting wrap-up to a story that constantly subverts expectations. Scott gets the love he sought but has to lose his life, either literally or metaphorically. This makes his hard-won victory bittersweet. Scott’s journey also comes full circle; the tale starts with him dying after a breakup and ends with him dying after finally finding new love.

While the movie chose to spell out Scott’s survival, the comics intentionally leave things uncertain. This makes the graphic novels’ endings much more layered, complex, and open to interpretation. The debate around what really happens to Scott Pilgrim will likely rage on among fans for years to come. So what do you think—did Scott die or somehow survive at the end? The comics invite you to endlessly revisit this question without ever providing a concrete resolution.